Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Photo Gallery Suggestions
In short: Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million after finding that the Facebook Android app read about 20 million Italian users' photos, videos and metadata for a gallery-suggestions feature without specific consent — relying instead on one vague, app-wide permission switched on by default. Meta must now get separate, explicit consent for the feature and keep it off by default, even for users who'd already granted the general system permission. This doesn't change ad targeting rules directly, but it's another reminder that "one broad permission, on by default" is no longer good enough for EU regulators, and the same scrutiny applies to anything advertisers ask customers to opt into.
- The fine, €805 million, is for a specific feature: Facebook Android reading users' photos, videos and metadata since 2023 to suggest gallery content, using one app-wide permission rather than specific consent.
- About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The case started from a July 2025 complaint and ran about 16 months before this decision.
- The Garante's reasoning: a single catch-all permission, a vague notice, and a default-on setting don't add up to valid consent under Italy's ePrivacy-derived rules.
- Meta has to fix this going forward — separate consent for the feature, off by default even for users who already granted the general permission — and report back to the regulator at one, two and three months.
- The fine works out to roughly 0.47% of Meta's worldwide turnover. The Garante chose not to pass the case to Ireland's Data Protection Commission, which usually handles Meta's EU-wide GDPR cases.
- Separately, OpenAI launched ChatGPT Wallet on 13 November, letting its AI agents complete purchases via a biometric check and a stand-in card credential, built with Amex, Mastercard and Visa — limited for now to US ChatGPT Pro subscribers.
What Italy fined Meta for
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million over a feature in the Facebook Android app: since 2023, the app has read users' photos, videos and metadata on their device to suggest content for a photo gallery feature. The problem wasn't the feature itself — it was how consent for it was handled. The app relied on a single, app-wide permission, with a vague notice, switched on by default. The Garante found that doesn't meet the bar for "specific and informed" consent.
About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The case began with a complaint from a Bolzano consumer group in July 2025 and took roughly 16 months to reach this decision.
What Meta has to do now
- Get separate, specific consent for the gallery-suggestions feature — a general device-permission grant is no longer enough.
- Keep the feature off by default, including for users who had already granted the broader permission previously.
- Report back to the Garante after one, two and three months confirming the changes are in place.
The fine itself comes to roughly 0.47% of Meta's worldwide turnover — modest in percentage terms, but notable because the Garante chose to handle this itself rather than route it through Ireland's Data Protection Commission, which usually leads Meta's EU-wide GDPR enforcement. Whether gallery data was used to train AI models wasn't part of this investigation.
What this means if you advertise to users in the EU
This ruling is about a device-permission feature, not ad targeting directly — it doesn't change Meta Ads policy or what you can target on. But it's a useful signal of where EU privacy enforcement is heading, and the same logic applies to anything you ask your own customers to opt into:
- A single broad permission or checkbox doesn't cover multiple uses of someone's data. If your own site or app bundles consent for several things into one toggle (marketing emails, personalization, data sharing), regulators are increasingly treating that the same way the Garante treated Meta's gallery permission — not valid for each individual use.
- Default-on settings are a growing liability, not just a UX convenience. If something uses personal data beyond what's strictly necessary, "on by default, opt-out if you notice" is the exact pattern being fined here.
- This sits alongside other EU moves tightening the same area — the proposed Digital Fairness Act (covered separately) would push further in this direction for dark patterns and consent generally.
Running ads or collecting leads from EU traffic and unsure if your own consent flows would hold up to this kind of scrutiny? Request a free account review.
Get new marketing updates in your inbox.
We email you when we publish something worth your time. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Sources
Facts in this article come from the sources above, checked on 17 November 2026. Platform features roll out in phases, so check your own account before acting. We update this page when official details change.
